What if Musk loses the Twitter case however defies the court docket?

Different authorized observers say such defiance is nearly not possible to think about, even from a famously combative persona reminiscent of Musk. He acknowledged he may lose in August in explaining why he abruptly bought practically $US7 billion price of Tesla shares.


“I take him at his phrase,” stated Ann Lipton, an affiliate regulation professor at Tulane College. “He desires to win. Possibly he’s received his personal judgment as to what the chances are. However he’s additionally being kind of sensible about this. He’s getting some money prepared so he doesn’t should dump his Tesla shares if it seems he’s ordered to purchase the corporate.”

A ruling of particular efficiency may drive Musk to pay up his $US33.5 billion private stake within the deal; the value will increase to $US44 billion with promised financing from backers reminiscent of Morgan Stanley.

The Delaware court docket has powers to implement its orders, and will appoint a receivership to grab a few of Musk’s property, particularly Tesla inventory, if he doesn’t comply, in line with Tom Lin, a regulation professor at Temple College.

The court docket has made such strikes earlier than, reminiscent of in 2013 when it held Chinese language firm ZTS Digital Networks in contempt and appointed a receiver with energy to grab its property. However after coercive sanctions didn’t work, the receiver requested the court docket 5 years later to problem bench warrants calling for the arrest of two senior executives the following time they visited the US.

Hypothesis that Musk could possibly be threatened with jail time for failing to adjust to a ruling is unrealistic, stated Berger. “Not less than, not for the Court docket of Chancery,” stated the previous decide. “That’s not the best way the court docket operates.”

However extra essential, Lin stated Musk’s authorized advisers will strongly urge him to adjust to the rulings of a court docket that routinely takes instances involving Tesla and different corporations included within the state of Delaware.

“In case you are an government at a serious American company included in Delaware, it’s very onerous so that you can do enterprise and defy the chancery court docket’s orders,” Lin stated.

Issues about Musk’s compliance derive from his previous behaviour coping with numerous arms of the federal government. In a long-running dispute with the US Securities and Change Fee, he was accused of defying a securities fraud settlement that required that his tweets be authorised by a Tesla legal professional earlier than being printed. He publicly feuded with California officers over whether or not Tesla’s electrical automotive manufacturing unit ought to stay shut throughout the early phases of the COVID-19 pandemic.


He’s additionally taken a combative strategy in Delaware Chancery Court docket, calling an opposing legal professional a “unhealthy human being” whereas defending Tesla’s 2016 acquisition of SolarCity towards a lawsuit that blamed Musk for a deal rife with conflicts of curiosity and damaged guarantees. He and his attorneys produce other Delaware instances nonetheless pending, together with one involving his compensation bundle at Tesla.

“I believe we’ve received an entire lot of gamers who, as free a cannon as Elon Musk is, depend on the goodwill of the Delaware courts on an ongoing foundation for his or her companies,” Lipton stated.

Musk’s argument for successful his newest Delaware case largely rests on his allegation that Twitter misrepresented the way it measures the magnitude of “spam bot” accounts which might be ineffective to advertisers. However most authorized specialists consider he faces an uphill battle in convincing Chancellor Kathaleen St Jude McCormick, the court docket’s head decide who’s presiding over the case, that one thing modified for the reason that April merger settlement that justifies terminating the deal.

The trial begins on October 17 and whichever facet loses can attraction to the Delaware Supreme Court docket, which is anticipated to behave swiftly. Musk and Twitter may additionally settle the case earlier than, throughout or after the trial, attorneys stated.

Delaware’s courts are well-respected within the enterprise world and any transfer to flout them could be “surprising and surprising”, stated Paul Regan, affiliate professor of Widener College’s Delaware Legislation College who has practiced in Delaware courts for the reason that Nineteen Eighties. “If there was some form of disaster like that, I believe the reputational hurt could be all on Musk, not the court docket.”


The Enterprise Briefing publication delivers main tales, unique protection and professional opinion. Signal as much as get it each weekday morning.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.