Unique-Michigan police ask prosecutors to think about charging Republican clerk in voting-system breach By Reuters

By Nathan Layne

(Reuters) – A Michigan township official who promotes false conspiracy theories of a rigged 2020 election may face legal prices associated to 2 voting-system safety breaches, in line with beforehand unreported information and authorized specialists.

A state police detective advisable that the Michigan legal professional common contemplate unspecified prices amid a months-long probe into one breach associated to the Republican clerk’s dealing with of a vote tabulator, in line with a June e mail from the detective to state and native officers. Reuters obtained the e-mail via a public-records request.

The clerk, Stephanie Scott, oversaw voting in rural Adams Township till the state final 12 months revoked her authority over elections. Scott has publicly embraced baseless claims that the 2020 election was rigged towards former U.S. President Donald Trump and has posted on-line in regards to the QAnon conspiracy idea.

In a second breach of the township’s voting system, the clerk gave a file containing confidential voter information to an information-technology skilled who’s a suspect in different alleged Michigan election-security violations. The skilled, Benjamin Cotton, labored with voter-fraud conspiracists looking for unauthorized entry to election techniques in different states, in line with court docket information reviewed by Reuters. The incident has not been beforehand reported.

Scott denies any wrongdoing. The legal professional common and state police declined to touch upon the allegations towards the clerk.

Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson, the highest election official on this battleground state, stripped Scott of her authority over elections final 12 months after the clerk refused to carry out common upkeep and accuracy testing on voting tools. Scott believed, incorrectly, that the method would erase 2020 election information, which she believed would possibly include fraud proof.

Scott’s actions are a part of a nationwide effort by public officers and others looking for proof of Trump’s false stolen-election claims. The allegations towards Scott have parallels to the high-profile case of Tina Peters, the clerk in Mesa County, Colorado, who enjoys cult-hero standing within the election-conspiracy motion and faces felony prices associated to comparable voting-system breaches.

Scott’s case illustrates what some election-security specialists describe as a rising insider menace from officers tasked with safeguarding American democracy. Reuters has documented 18 incidents nationally, 12 of them in Michigan, by which public officers and others are accused of breaching or making an attempt to breach election techniques. Such violations can expose confidential voter info and allow election-tampering by revealing safety protocols.

“The insider menace query is what retains many individuals up at evening,” mentioned Matthew Weil, government director of the Democracy Program on the Bipartisan Coverage Middle, a assume tank.

If charged, Scott would turn out to be the second elected clerk nationally to face legal prosecution associated to a safety breach following the November 2020 election. The Mesa County district legal professional accuses Peters of serving to an unauthorized individual make copies of her voting machine exhausting drives. She has pleaded not responsible to 10 legal counts, together with seven felonies, and is about to go to trial in March.

Each Peters and Scott have insisted that they had an obligation to analyze fraud allegations. Peters didn’t reply to a request for remark.


The vote-tabulator breach got here to gentle in October 2021, shortly after state officers stripped Scott of her authority over township elections. The secretary of state ordered the clerk to show over tools and information to the Hillsdale county clerk. County officers quickly found a part of the tabulator, referred to as the scan unit pill, was lacking.

The pill, which officers describe because the brains of the tabulator, comprises election information and proprietary vendor software program. State police obtained a search warrant to retrieve it, kicking off a legal investigation. Police discovered it in a locked cupboard in Scott’s workplace, in line with a police report.

On June 24, Michigan State Police Detective Sergeant Jay Barkley emailed county and state officers to supply an replace on the investigation. “I’ve not too long ago submitted this case to the Lawyer Basic’s Workplace for evaluation for doable legal prices,” Barkley wrote.

Barkley’s e mail didn’t specify what prices the legal professional common ought to contemplate. It famous that prosecutors requested extra details about Scott’s actions.

Scott’s second election-security breach – the discharge of confidential voter information to an unauthorized expertise skilled – was disclosed in July by Scott’s personal lawyer, Stefanie Lambert. Reuters is reporting it for the primary time now.

Lambert, a key determine within the election-conspiracy motion, represents Scott in a lawsuit she filed towards state officers, alleging they improperly stripped the clerk of her authority over elections. Lambert, making an attempt to show voter fraud in Adams Township, filed an affidavit from Cotton, the expertise specialist. Lambert offered Cotton as an skilled witness who had analyzed the township’s voting information and located irregularities.

Cotton mentioned within the sworn assertion that unnamed Adams Township officers gave him entry to the city’s digital pollbook. Scott later admitted at an Aug. 8 township board assembly that she had given Cotton the information, in line with video of the assembly reviewed by Reuters.

The pollbook exhibits who voted on Nov. 3, 2020, and comprises legally confidential voter information together with driver license and delivery date info. State election legislation prohibits the disclosure of such personal voter information to unauthorized folks.

Lisa Brown, the Democratic clerk of Oakland County, close to Detroit, referred to as sharing the digital pollbook information with unauthorized folks a “enormous no-no,” compromising voter privateness. Such recordsdata are password-protected, she mentioned, which means an Adams Township official probably shared login credentials.

Lambert didn’t touch upon why she selected to reveal an unauthorized launch of voter information that would end in legal penalties towards her shopper, or on the allegations towards Scott. Cotton didn’t reply to a request for remark.

Scott advised Reuters she believes {that a} state legislation allowed her to seek the advice of exterior specialists, reminiscent of Cotton, to assist her examine if she suspected election fraud. The Michigan secretary of state’s workplace declined to touch upon that authorized idea.

Cotton is the founding father of a digital forensics agency who has labored with election conspiracists in Maricopa County, Arizona and nationally. He mentioned in a sworn assertion in an Arizona lawsuit that he had additionally examined election techniques in Espresso County, Georgia – the location of one other voting-system breach by pro-Trump activists – and within the Mesa County, Colorado workplace run by Peters, the clerk going through felony prices.

Lambert was beforehand sanctioned, and faces doable disbarment, for her function in a federal lawsuit looking for to overturn Trump’s 2020 election loss in Michigan. She and Cotton are amongst 9 folks below investigation by a particular prosecutor in Michigan for an alleged conspiracy to achieve unauthorized entry to voting tools in a case that includes alleged breaches throughout the state.

Scott’s lawsuit was dismissed final week by Michigan Court docket of Claims Choose Douglas Shapiro, who cited the clerk’s failure to correctly signal and confirm her grievance.

Three election legislation specialists advised Reuters that Scott may face legal penalties over the 2 election-security violations in Adams Township. John Pirich, a retired Michigan legal professional who represented Trump in an election-related 2016 lawsuit, mentioned Scott may face misdemeanor or felony prices and was “at nice danger” of legal prosecution, “as would any clerk in the event that they did this.”

Pirich, who can be a former Michigan assistant legal professional common, mentioned state police would sometimes solely ask prosecutors to think about prices if investigators believed that they had proof to assist them.


Michigan has been a central goal of the election-conspiracy motion, however greater than 250 audits have confirmed the previous president’s loss right here.

Cotton, the IT skilled, claimed in his affidavit to have discovered deviations between the township’s pollbook information and state information that prompt doable fraud. He asserted that dozens of names distinctive to the state’s information weren’t recorded within the pollbook, and vice versa. All advised, the variations raised questions on 11.5% of the 1,362 votes in Adams Township on Election Day, the affidavit claims.

When the affidavit was filed in court docket, Scott’s legal professional, Lambert, was interviewed by Joe Oltmann, a right-wing conspiracy theorist and host of the “Conservative Each day” podcast. She mentioned Cotton had discovered “robust circumstantial proof” of election-rigging.

Marney Kast, the Republican clerk in Hillsdale County mentioned her workplace rejected such assertions after conducting its personal examination of township and state information. Any discrepancies Cotton may need discovered, she mentioned, may replicate the traditional ongoing motion of voters out and in of the district – and don’t show fraud.

“I’m not positive what information Mr. Cotton was ,” she mentioned. “The overall variety of voters matched the pollbook – 1,362.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.