Blow for Scottish nationalists as UK court docket rejects independence vote bid By Reuters


© Reuters. Professional-Scottish independence campaigners protest outdoors the UK Supreme Courtroom as a case continues to resolve whether or not the Scottish authorities can maintain a second referendum on independence subsequent yr with out approval from the British parliament, in Lo


By Michael Holden and Andrew MacAskill

LONDON (Reuters) – The Scottish authorities can’t maintain a second referendum on independence with out approval from the British parliament, the UK’s high court docket dominated on Wednesday, dealing a hammer blow to nationalists’ hopes of holding a vote subsequent yr.

Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, chief of the pro-independence Scottish Nationwide Social gathering (SNP), had introduced earlier this yr she supposed to carry an advisory vote on secession subsequent October, however that it needed to be lawful and internationally recognised.

After the UK Supreme Courtroom dominated she couldn’t accomplish that with out the approval of the UK parliament, she repeated her vow to marketing campaign within the subsequent UK-wide election, anticipated to be held in 2024, solely on a platform of whether or not Scotland ought to be impartial, making it a “de facto” referendum.

“We should and we are going to discover one other democratic, lawful and constitutional means by which the Scottish folks can categorical their will. For my part, that may solely be an election,” Sturgeon informed reporters.

“As of at this time, democracy is what’s at stake … It’s now about whether or not or not we even have the fundamental democratic proper to decide on our personal future,” she stated.

In a referendum in 2014, Scots rejected ending the more-than 300-year-old union with England by 55% to 45%, however nationalists argue that the vote for Brexit two yr later, which nearly all of Scottish voters opposed, modified every little thing.

Nonetheless, the British authorities in London has repeatedly stated it could not grant permission for one more plebiscite, saying it ought to be a once-in-a-generation occasion.

In a unanimous verdict of 5 judges, the Supreme Courtroom dominated the Scottish authorities couldn’t go laws paving the best way for an advisory second referendum with out the approval of the UK parliament.

“We respect the clear and definitive ruling of the Supreme Courtroom,” British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak stated.

“I believe that the folks of Scotland need us to be engaged on fixing the foremost challenges that we collectively face, whether or not that is the economic system, supporting the NHS (Nationwide Well being Service), or certainly supporting Ukraine, now’s the time for politicians to work collectively.”


Underneath the 1998 Scotland Act, which created the Scottish parliament and devolved some powers from Westminster, all issues referring to the Union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England are reserved to the UK parliament. The court docket concluded any referendum, even advisory, could be a reserved matter.

Sturgeon’s left-wing SNP, which has dominated Scottish politics for greater than a decade and received the overwhelming majority of Scottish seats within the 2019 UK election, has argued that the refusal of the British authorities to permit one other vote means the views of Scots are being ignored.

SNP president Michael Russell informed Reuters that calling a de facto referendum was of venture as a result of his celebration may fail to win greater than half the votes on the subsequent election. However, he stated the court docket ruling confirmed the UK was not a voluntary partnership of countries.

The UK authorities place “primarily says to the folks of Scotland that your votes do not matter,” he stated. “That may be a very silly factor for any authorities to say to a inhabitants.”

London argues it’s mistaken to carry one other divisive independence vote throughout a price of residing and vitality disaster, whereas battle rages in Ukraine and the nation recovers from the coronavirus pandemic.

Independence campaigners say it ought to be for Scotland to resolve how to answer these main points, provided that the right-wing British authorities is unpopular in Scotland, the place assist for Sunak’s Conservative Social gathering is presently operating at about 15% in accordance with newest polls.

Greater than a dozen pro-independence rallies are deliberate throughout Scotland and elements on Europe on Wednesday with the biggest anticipated outdoors the Scottish parliament in Edinburgh the place supporters will declare that democracy is being denied.

Ought to there be a second referendum, polls counsel voters stay evenly break up and a vote could be too near name, with what foreign money an impartial Scotland would use or whether or not it may rejoin the EU, the important thing points.

Critics say Sturgeon and the SNP have did not reply these questions adequately.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.